instabilities in risa-3d with flexible diaphragms

Instabilities in RISA-3D with Flexible Diaphragms

In a model that contains both RISAFloor and RISA-3D data it is possible to define your diaphragms as either flexible or rigid for lateral design. You can do this from the Diaphragms spreadsheet in either program:

Flexible Diaphragm Instability2 300x77 2x

Rigid diaphragms will create a rigid link mesh in RISA-3D that makes the diaphragm act as a rigid body. There is a physical effect on your model that affects the analysis by locking all nodes at the diaphragm level together.

Flexible diaphragms act solely as a load attribution mechanism. The program calculates the tributary area to the lateral force resisting elements and applies the load to the collectors. However, there is no physical effect on the analysis.

The flexible diaphragm behavior can cause lateral stability problems with your model. Here is an example where this could be a problem:

Flexible Diaphragm Instability1

In this scenario our braced frames in our flexible diaphragm model have no out-of-plane stability provided, as the diaphragm has no physical effect on the model. When we solve this model we will receive instabilities in the solution.

Flexible Diaphragm Instability5

To handle this scenario we will use very small spring boundary conditions in the out-of-plane directions on the frames.

Flexible Diaphragm Instability3

These are dummy boundary conditions of course. Because the springs are very flexible they take very little load out of the system while providing stability to our model. ALWAYS check the reactions at these dummy supports to make sure that the reactions are small. After solving we have now gotten rid of any instability messages and we can confirm that the reactions are very minimal.

Flexible Diaphragm Instability4